Beyond Mainstream
Social icon element need JNews Essential plugin to be activated.
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • JOURNALISTS
  • NEWS OUTLETS
  • FIREBRANDS / CONTROVERSIAL
  • SATIRE
  • DOT CONNECTORS / TRUE HISTORY
  • WHISTLEBLOWERS
  • EMPOWERED HEALTH
  • UFO/DUMBS
  • FINANCIAL
  • About Us
  • Home
  • JOURNALISTS
  • NEWS OUTLETS
  • FIREBRANDS / CONTROVERSIAL
  • SATIRE
  • DOT CONNECTORS / TRUE HISTORY
  • WHISTLEBLOWERS
  • EMPOWERED HEALTH
  • UFO/DUMBS
  • FINANCIAL
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Beyond Mainstream
No Result
View All Result

NZ Media Council upholds complaints against Stuff over unfair ‘transphobic’ story

Beyond Mainstream News by Beyond Mainstream News
May 31, 2023
in NEWS OUTLETS
0
Caretaker NZ leader, who wants to ditch monarchy, to meet with King

E-transfer (Canada):
[email protected] – password RebelNews if required

Cheques made out to Rebel News:
Rebel News Network Ltd.
PO Box 61056 Eglinton/Dufferin RO
Toronto, ON M6E 5B2

Crypto


SIGN THE PETITION: Let Avi Yemini in



SIGN THE PETITION: Let Avi Yemini in


Let the Aussie journalist report from New Zealand

26,830 signatures

Goal: 30,000 Signatures











“>
Secure


The New Zealand Media Council has affirmed complaints against a Stuff article that alleged unfair reporting practices.

The contentious story, School counsellor accused of ‘bullying’ and transphobia, was based on a Facebook post from Marli de Klerk, a counsellor at Bethlehem College in Tauranga, and subsequent reactions to it.

Ms de Klerk was reportedly labelled “transphobic” for her “damaging” and “prejudiced” views about the Ministry of Education curriculum in the article.

In her Facebook post, she suggested that the curriculum was “intentionally teaching falsehoods to youngsters” about gender issues. The controversial post has since been removed.

The Stuff piece quoted several individuals who disagreed with Ms de Klerk’s stance, among them a “health professional” and a psychotherapist. The article also linked a local arson event to anti-LGBTQ+ sentiment in Tauranga.

The Media Council received four separate complaints about the story.

All four highlighted the usage of the term ‘bullying’ in the headline, and expressed dissatisfaction with Stuff’s tardy correction and the ineffective removal of the term.

While Stuff did apologise for using the term, the apology was deemed insufficient as it was placed at the end of the article. One complainer noted that, despite the retraction of the article, Ms de Klerk had been erroneously labelled as a bully and transphobic, causing her undue harm.

The complainers further criticised the article’s reference to a ‘health practitioner’ who turned out to be an osteopath from Northland commenting on Ms de Klerk’s original post.

They argued that labelling her a ‘health practitioner’ insinuated expertise in gender matters, leading to an imbalance in the article.

The article was seen by all complainers as part of an ongoing campaign by Stuff against the Christian-based college regarding gender issues, with one suggesting the reporter be barred from covering these topics.

One complainer asserted that Ms de Klerk’s reasonable expectations of privacy were violated when responses to her personal post were transformed into a published article.

In defence, Stuff denied any bias in the article or by the journalist. They admitted that the headline should not have contained the term “bullying”, which they claim was promptly corrected.

The headline was changed, the location of the health professional was updated, information about a gender issues book endorsed by Bethlehem College was included, and an apology was added at the article’s end.

Stuff maintained that alternative views were not included as the article was not part of a broader debate. They defended quoting the osteopath who had commented extensively on the Facebook post, stating her occupation was irrelevant to the story. The inclusion of the arson incident was justified as fair comment and relevant to the issues raised.

The Council upheld the complaints under Principle (1) for lack of fairness, noting it was a major error to accuse Ms de Klerk of bullying in the headline. Despite Stuff’s correction, an internet search continues to display the original headline. Other principles did not warrant the remaining complaints.

The complete Media Council ruling can be accessed on its official website.

Source link

https://www.rebelnews.com/nz_media_council_upholds_complaints_against_stuff_over_unfair_transphobic_story

Previous Post

OMG Podcast Episode #1 – O’Keefe & Kennedy drops TOMORROW for Subscribers ONLY. Join today!

Next Post

My latest Newsletter! Hot off the Presses! I used to write books, now I write newsletters! This one is juicy and full. N…

Next Post
My latest Newsletter! Hot off the Presses! I used to write books, now I write newsletters! This one is juicy and full. N…

My latest Newsletter! Hot off the Presses! I used to write books, now I write newsletters! This one is juicy and full. N...

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Browse by Category

  • DOT CONNECTORS / TRUE HISTORY
  • EMPOWERED HEALTH
  • FINANCIAL
  • FIREBRANDS / CONTROVERSIAL
  • JOURNALISTS
  • NEWS OUTLETS
  • SATIRE
  • UFO/DUMBS
  • WHISTLEBLOWERS

CATEGORIES

  • DOT CONNECTORS / TRUE HISTORY
  • EMPOWERED HEALTH
  • FINANCIAL
  • FIREBRANDS / CONTROVERSIAL
  • JOURNALISTS
  • NEWS OUTLETS
  • SATIRE
  • UFO/DUMBS
  • WHISTLEBLOWERS
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
Social icon element need JNews Essential plugin to be activated.

© 2023 Beyond Mainstream - All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • JOURNALISTS
  • NEWS OUTLETS
  • FIREBRANDS / CONTROVERSIAL
  • SATIRE
  • DOT CONNECTORS / TRUE HISTORY
  • WHISTLEBLOWERS
  • EMPOWERED HEALTH
  • UFO/DUMBS
  • FINANCIAL
  • About Us

© 2023 Beyond Mainstream - All rights reserved.